16 October 2011

Why Russians in Israel don’t want peace

Bill Clinton is right: Israelis from the ex-USSR  are not really interested in a peace agreement.  Clinton’s claims that Russian-descendent Israelis are an obstacle to peace can be understood in different ways. But excluding their emotional component, one must  recognize that the immigrants from the former Soviet Union are mostly opposed to the peace process itself and here's probably why.

The rose-colored glasses of “multiculturalism” hide the fact that there are three civilizations in this world: postmodern liberal democracies, states of classical political culture and traditional patriarchal communities.

As Western civilization passionately abandons its national-religious idea, just as fervently the other two insist on their own values and originality.

In Europe, the ideological divide between these two cultures passes along the border of the former Eastern Bloc. Eastern European countries, irrespective of their economic successes or level of democratic development, are strikingly different from their neighbors in the West. Because of Nazism and communism, repressions and totalitarian ideology, they are hardened to senseless slogans, illusions and idealistic dogmatism.

Eastern Europe and the Far East countries derive vital strength from their history, mythology and tradition. They are developed communities but also inseparably tied to their past, and it is not so important whether this connection gets a religious or cultural frame.

THE MAIN issue is not politics. It is the cult of national dignity, mistrust of universalist theories and a resistance to any trespassing of their space, both geographical and spiritual.

It is impossible to imagine a Ukrainian leader bowing to a Middle Eastern sheikh, or a Polish prime minister kissing the hand of an African despot.

Hindus will not build a mosque near the site of one of the bloodiest terrorist attacks; Serbs don’t feel guilty toward the Albanians of Kosovo who deprived them of their heritage; Russian intellectuals, actors and academics don’t wish to “understand” the Chechen insurgents, who carried out terrible acts of terrorism in their country.

Have you ever heard about Czechs regretting the transfer of the Sudeten Germans? Are Bulgarians sorry for the exile of 250,000 Turks in the 1950s? AND, FINALLY, there is the third group of people in the world still living in the dynamics of patriarchal-feudal relations.

Absent trappings of Western civilization (cellphones, Internet, laptops, etc.), much of Arab and African landscape is  a gloomy and cruel world. This is a world where clan norms and blood feud laws rule, where, largely, women are considered inferior to men. Adultery is punished by stoning, and rivals are eliminated with explosives, “road accidents” and poisons.

Everything considered different, from sexual orientation to critical discourse is met with censure.

It's a world of a patriarchal economy concentrated in the hands of a few, the gap between rich and poor, and some terrifying traditions and beliefs.

SOME IN the West voluntarily make themselves hostages to the patriarchal world, but classical culture resists to this selfdestructive tendency.

Israel is a state with a mosaic society. It consists of different groups of populations, from postmodernists to natives of patriarchal countries of Asia and Africa, to “Russians.” For postmodernists, Israel is no more than a hindrance on their way to utopia, and the word “peace” has sacral sense. For “Russians” in Israel, peace with feudal-patriarchal societies has no value because they don’t trust them. They put their own survival above illusions and doubtful experiments. They know the price of the “peace” which Clinton has established in Kosovo.

According to such “peace” the Serbs of Kosovo had a choice between exile and death.

The writer is a reporter at the Russian-language weekly Novosty Nedely. He came to Israel from Moscow in 1988 and is the author of Ways of God and coauthor of Jewish Atlantida (in Russian).

Original article


Anonymous said...

Saw the article. Like the idea that the modern spin has a part to play,.

Anyways pop by to say hello to us on www.politicalworld.org

in the vanguard said...

They are a very good counterweight against the poisonous "peace now" maniacs.